Score: 9

"Decent"

submission: Dreamwalker

date: June 28, 2008

It's a decent track that you have hear although it sounds to be pretty busy and also quite loud too, which is okay if people like that kind of thing. But to me, it can just sound a little too loud, caused by the mass of instuments I belive, though it does get a little less busy later on which is good. The middle part is very nice and I like that, kind of calm in a way, it's very good there.

The whole thing does come together well, so no real problems with the structure of it and the time is used very well, so good job with that. It is definatly not repetitive though, which is brillient, but to me it doesn't really sound to fit in with the title too well, I mean parts do, which is good but other parts don't. Overall though, this is definatly a good track, good work on this.

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 10

"Nice Work"

submission: ==(Ice Desert called Earth)==

date: June 22, 2008

I like the sound of this tune, it's very calm and has a good beat to it all the way through the whole thing, which is good to hear. The opening had a very good sound to it and I thought that was done very well and the quietness of parts through the main part of this is also good where it becomes slightly quieter, so good work with that.

There's nothing I can really suggest here, I mean I think everything in this does come together very well, although I must say that it does maybe sound a little repetitive for most of the part. The slow building down on the ending part to this sounds good and seems to stick with the rest of the feeling of the main song, so great work on that and overall.

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Eheh"

submission: Carbon Baby (part 2)

date: June 22, 2008

I'm not too keen on this one on a whole, it really sounds a little too busy in most parts and kind of too loud and in a way that can't really be controled with the volume without hurting the quality of the whole track. I mean there are parts of this which do sound very good and a little softer but many other parts here just seem too loud for my liking.

I'm not too keen on the whole fuzzy kind of beats, it's more the opening half where the problem is for me though I must say. It does seem to loop pretty well which is kind of good and the ending is done very well, so good work with that, it's more just that the whole thing is too fuzzy for me :s

4/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 10

"Dark"

submission: - [This Was Meant To Be] -

date: June 22, 2008

This song certainly has a very dark sound to it in a way, but it does sound very good, I really like the intro and the ending to this song, they both sound very good. As does the main part of the whole thing, it does sound to be maybe repetitive in parts but it does really work and I belive the length of this shows that you have used the time well, there is nothing bad about the length, infact I thought it was good.

The way everything comes together is also very well done and such, I can't hear anything wrong with this track, nothing I belive could be changed either, everything really comes together well, even if it does sound a little dark, which isn't all to my taste, but I still like it, good work.

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Intresting"

submission: Example I - Dream

date: June 21, 2008

Well it sounds pretty intresting for most part, though one thing I should really say is the ending, I'm not really keen on it, you have it ending on the same note and for too long in my view, it doesn't really seem to work here, simply fading it out might have been much better. The start of this is okay though and does sound pretty good.

Everything sounds to be played pretty well and there isn't anything that stands out as sounding too bad, other than the ending. But there isn't really anything here that stands out a whole lot either anyway, could have done with a little more to it.

3/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 7

"Kind of Quiet"

submission: Improvisation Number One

date: June 21, 2008

It's kind of quiet for most part which is maybe a little disappointing, like the start seems to be too much silence and there are many other parts of this which are a little too silent for my liking. But then where there is a tune, it does sound very good and the main middle part seems to sound very good to me and I like that part of the tune, in my view it is just a shame that there is so much silance in this.

The ending is okay but could have been better, if you had ended it with some slower playing as oppose to one final louder sound, it might have been good and leaving a silant for consistancy. But like I say, where you do have a tune, it is good, so nice work on that.

4/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Okay"

submission: Old School Battle

date: June 21, 2008

Well it's not too bad, it's pretty decent to listen to so there is nothing really wrong with it, though it doesn't really sound like a whole lot on its own, it could probably be used for something. The loop here is pretty decent, though maybe just a little off right at the end, might want to try to work that out if you can notice it yourself.

It is very short and could get quite annoying to listen to over and over, so whatever it's used for should have other distractions and such so it doesn't get too annoying to the person using whatever it is used for. Otherwise, this is a pretty decent loop you have made.

3/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 10

"Nice Tune"

submission: .:Lost In Her Eyes:.

date: June 21, 2008

This sounds very good, I mean it;s all played very well and everything, good work on this one. I have no real problems with this, although it's not really to my taste it still sounds very good. The opening build up sounds good, starts out to be pretty soft, the pause before the main louder part of this sounds good to, it really works and fits in well with everything.

The ending is the part I liked about this, not because it was the end, lol, not trying to say it sucks just so you know. I mean, it really works, the pauses there sound good, without looking at the time of the song, it sounded like the start and that it had looped, that confused me, but the ending did sound good, nice work on that.

Please don't try to confuse me next time though :(

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 6

"Too Short"

submission: Galaga Main Theme

date: June 21, 2008

It's really too short to really say a whole lot about it I have to say, a bit longer and it might be easier to say more. The loop for this is done pretty well and it does work well as a loop but the sound for me is just too sharp and it really gets annoying to listen to over and over, so in that sense it doesn't make a good loop. If it was a little softer, it would be much more plesent to listen to as well as longer, that would be good to.

2/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"So-So"

submission: Project Part 3 - Omega

date: June 21, 2008

Of all three of them, this is the one I don't like as much, I mean the ending of this is done pretty well and closes everything off very well but the opening sounds nothing like the ending part of the previous. There is nothing that actually sounds bad about this but the kind of 'boom' sound in this, I can say I'm not too keen on and does kind of ruin the rest of the tune to me.

The tune itself is good but with the interuptions of something sounding compleatly diffrent, it does kind of spoil it. Everything else sounds nice, kind of calm and that's the thing I like the most about this and the ending to the whole thing. The ending part to this changes to a dark kind of sound, which is okay and it does work with the final ending.

4/5

<3

= Review Request Club =