Score: 9

"Nice Intro"

submission: [TMM43]Heal

date: July 19, 2008

The intro to this was problaby the best thing I heard in this, although the rest of this song does come together very well, I though the intro was done very well, as was the ending to the whole thing, so both are good in that sence. I like the overall sound to this as well, it sounds very upbeat and energetic too, I think it all sounds to come together very well which is good to hear.

I can't hear anything wrong with this track as it is, so can't really suggest any room for improvment, a bit longer would have been nice but not really important as I think this is long enough as it is. So overall, very good work on this.

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 6

"Okay"

submission: Dont Listen To This Song!

date: July 19, 2008

Well it has an okay sound to it even if it is somewhat messy through the whole thing, it also does sound like it lacks a lot to it as well though. To me this whole track sounds more like the background for another song, though parts of this do have more of a beat to them than just a background music type sound.

There's not much more I can say about this though, I mean I'm not too keen on this overall as a track, the sort of hissing sounds are kind of annoying, though it does have the sound of a dark and unplesent underground room which I guess you could say is a good thing, lol.

2/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Pretty Nice"

submission: Song of Storms (Windmill Song)

date: July 19, 2008

The overall tune to this is very nice, kind upbeat in a way though for some other parts in this it sounds like it changes the mood of it, either that or it's cause by listerning to it over and over. But the tune itself is done pretty well and such, which is good to hear, no real problems with this since it all does sound like it comes together well.

Although there isn't too much veriation through this so it does sound a little repetitive after a while, a bit more noticiable change through the whole thing in parts would sound good if you could do that. I haven't heard the original so I can't really compare, but good job all the same.

4/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 3

"Owch"

submission: Tell Your Mother

date: July 19, 2008

That was pretty bad to say the least, I mean it's okay the first time but the looping this isn't a good idea but just on its own, it is very short so yeah. The voice is okay and the background also sounds pretty good, if there was more to this then I would say it was a little better but there isn't much here so I can't really.

Can't make out the background speaking much but it makes a nice background like that, if you had more after the opening sentance like tell her what or something, then it would be better, hmm.

1/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 9

"Alright"

submission: Ex Nihilum Remix

date: July 19, 2008

Well there's nothing too wrong with it on the whole but I do have a slight problem with some of the sounds in this, in a way they are a little flat to say the least, some parts of this sound like they are lacking some more energetic beats. The whole tune though does sound okay overall and everything does come together well to form a decent peice here.

The quality of the audio is fine and everything, which is good to hear and I do think both the opening intro and the ending bit are done well, so you have got a good start and finish with this track. I just think it lacks a little energy in some parts, you have it in others which is good.

4/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 10

"Nice Work"

submission: (TGF) Vulpus Overture Redux

date: July 19, 2008

This tune sounds very good and seems to come together very well, I can't hear any problems with this other than at the very start it seems to have a few seconds of silance, which I wasn't too keen on. The rest of this is good though, it's not repetitive and it has plenty of change through the whole thing so there is something diffrent for the listener to hear with this.

Though it's quite like a marching song to start with, it sounds to be kind of dark in a way, it does all sound good and everything fits together well. Much of the sound here is good, some very heavy beats in this, they work too and everything is played out very well in this, but I just prefer more upbeat tunes, lol.

5/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 6

"Alright Then"

submission: Oh My Goodness!

date: July 19, 2008

Well this isn't too bad but I think you have overused the same sentance a few to many times in this song, it's not bad for some of the things you have done to it but at the start, you used it quite a few too many times for my liking before the actual song started up. The song itself is kind of ammusing in points of this, the ending is pretty good as well as some of the effects.

I do also like the many beats you have in this, they all do work well, but I don't like the over use of the phrase "Oh My Goodness", even with more variation, this would have been better. The idea for this is good and such, it's almost there in my view but the repetitvness killed it, sorry.

2/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Neat Loop"

submission: Bass Loop AL

date: July 19, 2008

Okay so this loop is pretty good, I mean as well as being your first work this is okay and pretty decent. Although the ending part of this loop seems to mess up a little from what I can hear of it, seems to just go kind of sloppy, not sure if you can hear that yourself, lol. As for looping, it does seem to loop pretty well but there is a slight pause between the start and the end.

The main playing of the thing in this is okay and sounds pretty good from what I can hear of it, no problems with the main body of it, the only thing I'm not keen on is the ending. So other than that, good work on this loop, hope you can create things a little longer than this in the future.

3/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 7

"Not Bad"

submission: Chitarro

date: July 19, 2008

The overall sound of the tune is very upbeat and such, I do kind of like that which is a good thing, one major problem with this is the lack of change through the whole thing, it does sound nice but too repetitive which means it gets a little boring to listen to after a while. I also think that this could do with some more energetic beats too it, that would be good too.

The quality of the sound is good, I have no problems with that and the idea of the whole thing is good too, just the execution of the tune lets it down for me. Keep working at this kind of thing and I'm sure you will get it right at some point, just remember to have more veriation through the whole thing, lol.

3/5

<3

= Review Request Club =

Score: 8

"Okay"

submission: -Issue-

date: July 19, 2008

The sound for this is okay, I mean it comes together well and I have no problems hearing it although I use headphones myself too so yeah. Some parts of this I'm not too keen on like the large quiet bit in the middle part of this tune, well middlish, it sounded like it ended there till you started to build it back up, but just seemed like a waste to me.

Everything else seems to sound fine to me, no other problems except the silance in this, it also does seem to be a little repetitive too, which is quite a problem after a while, makes it sound a little boring you know. Anyway, other than the mentioned points, pretty good work.

3/5

<3

= Review Request Club =